In partnership with

🦆 CHILL THE DUCK OUT

Volume 030: The sweet spot between "everything's amazing" and "we're all doomed."

💭 Cold Open

Finding the sweet spot between delusional optimism and soul-crushing realism is a tightrope worth walking.

I've spent most of my life with my head firmly planted in the clouds. Not in a dreamy, poetic way. It’s been more of a "maybe if I just believe hard enough, this wildly impractical thing will work out exactly as I imagine it" kind of way. I've been the guy who sees every opportunity as a sure thing, every plan as foolproof, every outcome as inevitable success. It's exhausting being that optimistic. Also, occasionally painful when reality shows up with a bill for all that unfounded confidence.

My wife, on the other hand, has spent most of her life with her feet firmly planted on the ground. Sometimes underground. She's the person who sees all the ways things could go wrong, all the obstacles I conveniently ignored, all the reality I optimistically glossed over. She's not a pessimist. She just refuses to participate in my Hallmark-esque fantasies where everything works out because I really, really want it to.

For years, we were like this. Me, flying too close to the sun with wax wings I was absolutely certain would hold. Her, standing on solid ground pointing out that wax melts. I thought she was being negative. She thought I was being recklessly optimistic. We were both right, and we were both wrong.

But then life happened. Responsibilities increased. Professional commitments got real. Kids with their endless needs and expenses and the complete inability to care about my optimistic timelines. The world reminded us repeatedly that uncertainty exists and it can knock you down without warning or apology.

And somewhere in all of that, something shifted. I started coming down from the clouds a bit. Not all the way to the ground. I'm still fundamentally an optimist, but low enough to see the obstacles I used to fly over without noticing. My wife started looking up from the ground more often. Not all the way to the clouds. She's still fundamentally a realist, but high enough to see possibilities she used to dismiss as unlikely.

We found this middle space. This sweet spot between my "everything will definitely work out" and her "but what if it doesn't." It's not dramatic. It's not a personality transplant. It's just... comfort. When you find that balance, it becomes easier to focus on the here and now without dwelling too much on what went wrong in the past or getting too caught up in fantasy futures that may never arrive.

I still get swept away sometimes. I still have moments where I'm all optimism and no plan. And that's okay. The clouds are nice to visit. But I don't live there anymore. I live in this middle space where hope meets preparation, where optimism shakes hands with reality, where I can believe good things will happen while also acknowledging that sometimes they don't and that's just part of being human.

So this week, we're talking about realistic optimism. The science-backed sweet spot between Buddy the Elf and Eeyore, and why finding that balance might be the key to actually achieving the things you're optimistic about.

🧠 The Science Bit

Let's dig into why the middle ground between blind optimism and crushing realism is where the magic actually happens, backed by people who study this stuff instead of just arguing with their spouse about whether dreams need budgets.

Unrealistic optimism gets expensive.

Research shows that most humans suffer from what psychologists call "optimism bias", which is the tendency to believe we're less likely than others to experience negative events. Dr. Tali Sharot's work shows that about 80% of people overestimate their chances of positive outcomes. This is why you think you'll definitely finish that project on time despite never finishing any project on time, or that you'll be the exception to every statistic that applies to literally everyone else.

While moderate optimism correlates with better mental health and motivation, unrealistic optimism leads to poor planning, financial problems, and consistent disappointment. It's like showing up to a knife fight with positive vibes and wondering why that didn't work out. But before you decide to become a full-time pessimist, know that pessimism correlates with depression, anxiety, worse physical health, and lower life satisfaction. Dr. Martin Seligman's decades of research shows that people who expect the worst tend to give up faster, try less, and achieve less. Constantly preparing for disaster doesn't leave much mental energy for building anything good.

Realistic optimism is the sweet spot nobody talks about enough.

Dr. Gabriele Oettingen's research introduces "mental contrasting". This is imagining positive outcomes while also identifying obstacles that might get in the way. Her WOOP method (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan) demonstrates that people who combine optimistic goals with realistic obstacle planning achieve significantly better results than pure optimists or pessimists. It’s hope with a backup plan.

Research on "flexible optimism" shows that people who maintain positive expectations while adapting to reality as it unfolds show better mental health, higher achievement, and greater life satisfaction. Dr. Sandra Schneider did some work that demonstrates that optimists who can adjust their expectations based on feedback show better outcomes across life domains. It's not about giving up on hope. It's about updating your hope based on actual information, like a functional human being.

The growth mindset connection makes this even better.

Dr. Carol Dweck's growth mindset research fits perfectly here. "I'm not good at this yet, but I can get better with practice" beats both "I'm naturally talented so this will be easy" (unrealistic optimism) and "I'm bad at this so why bother" (pessimism). The sweet spot is believing in your ability to grow while being honest about where you're starting.

Other research by Dr. Charles Carver shows that realistic optimists experience less stress, better coping mechanisms, and higher wellbeing. When you expect good things but also prepare for challenges, you're neither blindsided by problems nor paralyzed by expecting them. You're just ready. Ready to work toward good outcomes while also ready to adapt when things don't go according to plan.

🍟 This Week’s Happytizer

This week, I want you to practice realistic optimism by taking one goal or hope you have and running it through a reality check that doesn't kill the dream, just makes it more achievable.

Pick an approach that feels most like you.

The WOOP Method (my personal favorite because it’s also fun to shout enthusiastically):

• Wish: Write down something you want to achieve or hope will happen

• Outcome: Imagine the best possible outcome in detail. How will it feel? What will change?

• Obstacle: Identify the main obstacle (internal or external) that might prevent this

• Plan: Create a specific if/then plan. "If [obstacle] happens, then I will [specific action]"

The Optimist/Realist Conversation:

• Write down your most optimistic take on a situation or goal

• Now write down your most realistic/pessimistic take on the same thing

• Read both. Where's the middle ground that honors both perspectives?

• What's a plan that accounts for obstacles while maintaining hope?

The Expectation Audit:

• List three things you're currently optimistic about

• For each one, ask: "What am I assuming will happen without effort?"

• What's one realistic action you could take to move each toward the outcome you want?

• Adjust your expectation based on your honest assessment of effort required

The Hope with a Backup Plan:

• Pick something you're hoping will work out

• Make your primary plan for the optimistic scenario

• Make a backup plan for if it doesn't work out

• Notice how having the backup plan actually makes you feel more capable, not less hopeful

The goal isn't to become a pessimist or kill your dreams. It's to add some scaffolding to your optimism so it can actually hold weight. Notice how it feels to hope for good things while also being honest about what it will take to get there.

🎉 Unsolicited Joy of the Week

Sometimes realistic optimism looks less like careful planning and more like finding the absolute absurdity in terrible situations. Over at BuzzFeed, people shared their most hilariously optimistic takes on genuinely crappy moments, and it's a masterclass in perspective and being realistic enough to admit when things are terrible, but optimistic enough to laugh about it anyway.

😂 Read all 25 hilariously optimistic takes at BuzzFeed

💬 Tell me about your optimism style

Are you a head-in-the-clouds optimist, a feet-on-the-ground realist, or somewhere in between?

📩 [email protected]

If this made you feel 1% more balanced between hope and reality, share this with a friend... or I'll start showing up at your door with vision boards in one hand and risk assessment spreadsheets in the other, forcing you to acknowledge both.

💪 Speaking of realistic optimism...

A more grounded view that I’ve taken to heart, especially since turning 40, is that I can’t veg out on the couch and somehow maintain my college swimmer physique through sheer optimism. Reality had other plans (and a dad bod). So I've made actual fitness a key part of my overall feeling better journey. Part of what’s making that successful has been adding creatine to my recovery routine. It’s not just great for gym rats. Research shows creatine supplementation can reduce symptoms of depression, improve memory, and combat mental fatigue. Your brain uses a ton of energy, and creatine helps keep those energy levels stable, which matters for mood regulation and cognitive function, not just muscle recovery.

Unmatched Quality. Proven Results. Momentous Creatine.

Creatine is one of the most effective and well-researched supplements for improving strength, power, recovery, and cognitive performance. Momentous Creatine contains Creapure®—the purest, pharmaceutical-grade creatine monohydrate—single-sourced from Germany for unmatched quality and consistency. Every batch is NSF Certified for Sport®, meaning it’s independently tested for safety, label accuracy, and banned substances.

With no fillers, no artificial additives, and clinically validated dosing, it embodies The Momentous Standard™—a commitment to science-backed formulas, transparency, and uncompromising quality. This is why it’s trusted by professional teams, Olympic athletes, and the U.S. military’s top performers.

Whether you’re starting your creatine journey or returning after a break, Momentous Creatine gives you the confidence of knowing you’re fueling your body with the very best—precisely formulated for results you can feel and trust.

Head to livemomentous.com and use code HIVE for up to 35% off your first order.

Elevate Your Performance

🫶 Duckin’ Done

That's Volume 030.

Here's to flying with your feet on the ground, dreaming with your eyes open, and finding comfort in the sweet spot.

Until next time: breathe deep, stay grounded in hope, and chill the duck out.

Jason

🔬 Behind the Curtain

In a world of either toxic positivity or doom-scrolling pessimism, finding the balance of realistic optimism has never been more important for mental health and actually achieving our goals. Tali Sharot's research documents the widespread optimism bias, while Martin Seligman's foundational work established how expectation styles affect life outcomes. Gabriele Oettingen's mental contrasting research and WOOP method demonstrate that combining optimistic goals with realistic obstacle planning produces superior results. Carol Dweck's growth mindset work and Charles Carver's studies on stress reduction show that believing in growth while acknowledging current reality leads to better wellbeing and achievement.